Showing posts with label Gulf Disaster. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gulf Disaster. Show all posts

Sunday, June 06, 2010

Interview with a Valdez Worker,Merle Savage, who has a Message...


This is Merle Savage, a Clean Up Worker from the Valdez Oil Spill of 1989.While blogging about the Current Gulf Oil Spill and the possible health effects for Clean Up workers and residents, Merle very nicely left a message and introduced herself in the comments. As the Gulf Oil Disaster continues, workers have been complaining of Flu Like Symptoms and variety of other complaints, and are now showing up at Emergency Rooms in the Gulf. BP has been dismissive of their complaints blaming Heat and even labeling complaints as " Food poisoning." Merle reached out because she too was concerned about the Workers health and safety.

So I read her work and links and I also called her and interviewed her by phone, as a nurse I wanted to hear her thoughts and concerns and learn from her. She has a message and as she had worked the Vadez Disaster and did have health complaints and concerns. She also explained that many of the workers had health issues at the time,they all had a variety of symptoms from working the Clean Up of the site, they had the "Valdez Crud".

The First part of her Letter caught my eye :
"The workers who are cleaning up the oil in the Gulf need to be aware of the chemicals that will be used. I am one of the 11,000+ cleanup workers from the Exxon Valdez oil spill (EVOS), who is suffering from health issues from that toxic cleanup, without compensation from Exxon.

My name is Merle Savage; a female general foreman during the Exxon Valdez oil spill (EVOS) beach cleanup in 1989, which turned into 21 years of extensive health deterioration for me, and many other workers. Dr. Riki Ott visited me in 2007 to explain about the toxic spraying on the beaches. She also informed me that Exxon's medical records and the reports that surfaced in litigation by sick workers in 1994, had been sealed from the public, making it impossible to hold Exxon responsible for their actions."

{ http://www.rikiott.com Riki Ott has been featured on numerous shows this past month and interviews and her interviews are on posts below.}
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
On interview Merle explained that they all worked long shifts and many did suffer the symptoms from being exposed to the oil and chemicals, they had respiratory symptoms, coughs,nasal and sinus irritation. Videos from that time people can be heard coughing and hacking in the background. She said they also had GI symptoms, as well.She said that they would wake up and go to sleep feeling that way with no end in sight, that it was common among workers to feel that way,"Fluish". I asked her if they were given respirators, or masks and she said no. She also repeated that she thought it would have helped to have masks as they were breathing the fumes in as they sprayed the rocks and coastline. She said that there were medical doctors and nurses available for assessment, but it's not clear why the Medical personnel did not intervene to provide better respiratory care or precautions for the coughing "Flu" plagued workers.

The other disturbing part of her story is that the Workers Health was not followed and that it does not sound like anyone other than Dr.Ott took an interest in their health after their important work cleaning the site. 11,000 Workers is a large number that should have been followed and offered followup medical care, after working such a hazardous site with exposure to Oil and Chemicals. Dr.Ott is currently down in the Gulf attempting to make certain that she can advocate for the Current Cleanup Workers health. It is true that there was a lawsuit and that might have prevented some sharing of data and documentation, but OSHA and NIOSH and CDC should have compiled and studied the data from this Event. And that data at this point would better protect current workers.

{ OSHA"s current factsheet for the Clean Up Workers does not fully address the Dispersant Issues or the respiratory risks. }
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Exxon developed the toxic spraying; OSHA, the Coast Guard, and the state of Alaska authorized the procedure; VECO and other Exxon contractors implemented it. Beach crews breathed in crude oil that splashed off the rocks and into the air -- the toxic exposure turned into chronic breathing conditions and central nervous system problems, along with other massive health issues. Some of the illnesses include neurological impairment, chronic respiratory disease, leukemia, lymphoma, brain tumors, liver damage, and blood disease. "

When I read this part of her letter, I was struck by the current use of COREXIT being used and the possible risks to Clean Up Workers. I asked her if they were given any information or extra protective equipment and she said no. She also very honestly described her symptoms and illnesses that lasted for years. She worked hard to fight the symptoms she was left with and to lead a vibrant life and to regain some balance of health. After reading what she wrote, one could not help but wonder, how many of that 11,000 were left damaged by the toxic burden of their Clean Up Efforts of 1989 ? And did any of them really get the help or care they needed ? And are we repeating those mistakes even now in the Gulf ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"My web site is devoted to searching for EVOS cleanup workers who were exposed to the toxic spraying, and are suffering from the same illnesses that I have. Our summer employment turned into a death sentence for many -- and a life of unending medical conditions for the rest of us – Exxon’s Collateral Damaged." { Merle Savage's Website : "Silence In the Sound"}

Merle's website is excellent, very helpful for all to read. But after reading her site, and watching Ricki Ott on video interviews, I am concerned as a Nurse as to why BP is in charge of the Health of the Current Clean up workers and is OSHA involved and EPA and NIOSH and CDC are they monitoring the health of the workers ? And why aren't respiratory masks being given to the workers ? And why is BP being allowed to work the workers for long shifts increasing the exposure risks ? And the "Floatels" and the "Tent Cities" that BP is supposedly planning , WHO will monitor worker health and safety on site ? IS it unreasonable 21 years after Valdez to hope that the Clean Up Workers Safety and Health would be better protected than the 1989 Workers ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I asked her what is the message that she would like to share with those watching the disaster unfold in the Gulf and also the Workers, here is her eloquent response:

"BP isn't going to tell the truth about how toxic the crude oil is. The President is listening to his advisors, who are uninformed about the 21 years of health issues from the Exxon Valdez workers, who were exposed to the crude oil. So who will the workers believe? BP has a cover their butt agenda, and Obama wants to kick someone's butt, and point blame at anyone. People in the Gulf have only one option, make their own judgement call, after getting the facts."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
(Merle's complete letter is in comments if you wish to contact her ).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
(Riki Ott video from June2nd post)
Dr. Ricki Ott Marine Biologist explains the Lessons from the Valdez Disaster:

Saturday, May 22, 2010

Dear President Obama , A Letter about the Gulf Disaster...


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"We are tied to the ocean and when we go back to the Sea, whether it is to sail or to watch, we are going back from whence we came."~ John F. Kennedy
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
( Note to readers,friends: This letter was sent today, and posted over Enigma Cafe early this am, I have decided to move it here. I have tried to post unbiased reports and updates.But I need to post this.In my earlier post I encouraged that we all write and call President Obama. We all did write letters and call during the HCR debate and I think it helped the President to refocus.)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dear President Obama,
Millions of us worked to get you elected. We worked for you because we believed that you were the kind of man that when Trouble came Knocking you would be up to the challenge. A man of wisdom, integrity,and a man wise enough to have the Integrity to listen to Wisdom. There is Trouble knocking, but there is also Wisdom knocking on your door, and I worry you are not listening. Millions of Americans are watching the Disaster in the Gulf unfold. Many are Scientists who are worried about the Situation because they have the Wisdom to see what is going on and what it holds in the Future.

Millions of People need answers and assurances that your Leadership is committed to Them, but placing BP in charge of the Disaster the message to the People is that BP a Corporation is more important than them. For the Gulf residents that were abandoned, shunned, lied to, exploited and mistreated during and after Katrina, your Leadership is Critical at this time. Instead they have been given a BP hotline for everything for Dead Oiled Carcasses, Fume Reports and Questions about Seafood. And they have watched BP lie about the Gusher and yet they are supposed to call BP for wounded animals ? And they see that EPA is working with BP while hundreds of thousands of gallons of Toxic Dispersant are poured into their gulf. Yet has your administration reached out to the Fishermen , the Shrimpers, the Workers in the Gulf ? Have you offered them relief and Programs for this situation ? ( Again FEMA, National Guard, HLS have been sparingly sparsely committed and silently deployed) This is your moment to historically provide Aid and relief.

So far those Scientists have had no avenue to share their concerns and their skills. They have merely been tossed the BP phone number and told to leave a message. In this kind of Crisis Energy, Vision and Scientific Expertise should be harnessed and utilized. There are Scientists who have worked to protect the Gulf for years and now they would problem solve to save it or try to save what is left of it. ( Woodshole, Oceanography Programs across the Country, Engineering Programs ).Scientists who work with National Geographic and Sierra Club, NWF, NRDC etc all have people who have studied and prepared and protected Ecosystems for years they are not compromised by Greed of Oil Laden ambitions.

You have been given your first American Disaster of Epic Proportions and it was created by Corporate greed and mistakes.Yet the Company that is Responsible for the Disaster is still controlling the Crime Scene. 11 Good Men died in an Explosion and yet instead of hearing that the Justice Department is Investigating Americans are told that BP is now in charge of the Disaster. Can you see how unjust and corrupt that appears to Americans ? I have read the Justice Department is in NOLA,but you as President need to Announce that the Justice Department is investigating this Event and the Oil Slick.

Your Administration and even you should be giving Daily or bi-daily Briefings with NOAA, Coast Guard and EPA and DHHS issuing accurate Unbiased Uncompromised information regarding this Oil Slick. Hurricane Season is fast upon us, and this is your chance to help people prepare and work together to prevent panic and distress.

Mr.Gibbs has been mishandling the Pressers, mocking and dismissing Reporters concerns.Yet the Press Corps has been asking the same questions as millions of Americans have been asking. You need to acknowledge this anger, this frustration and angst. Americans watched on their TVs on May 18th when a CBS reporter was threatened with arrest for photographing Marshland Slime. The Reporter was told by a Coast Guard official that "BP is in charge". In that moment millions of Americans had their worst fear confirmed. BP not only owns the Disaster, they own the Gulf and Our Government Supports and Condones BP being in charge of this Disaster. The Message was that the Government has submitted Power to BP. And the Presser with Gibbs on the 20th and 21st confirmed this fear.

The Press needs to be able to report, interview Scientists, Fishermen, Residents and to take photos of the Dead Animals, the Damaged Gulf. This Crisis needs transparency and honesty and action. Silence will only be construed as part of the BP Coverup at this point. After numerous Coverups under the Bush Administration and 8 years of Lies, Americans are smart enough to KNOW they want Honesty and Leadership during this Disaster. We need you to do the Right Thing Now, Declare it a National Emergency.

Signed,
Just a Mom, Nurse,.....
Posted to the White House Website and mailed May 22, Day 32 of the Disaster in the Gulf


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Other People wrote excellent Letter to the President...must reads. If you find more please do send them to me.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
CNN :Tom Foreman's Letter to the President from May 22nd Eve. "Dear Mr. President #488 "In the name of the law, stop that oil!"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Here is a Must Read Letter by @Karoli , she really explains what is needed and mut be examined. Excellent Letter, share too please.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Paul Burke wrote a very poignant letter to the President the first week of the Disaster, April 29th. A friend in the NW sent it to me to point out that people have been watching and dreading what happens next.Sadly this post is prophetic.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This Must Read Letter to the President was written May 4th ( sent to me by a NRDC supporter). It is from the Switchboard, written by Frances Beinecke’s Blog "Three Steps Obama Should Take to Prevent Future Oil Disasters". The Switchboard is the Blog for the Staff of NRDC. This article clearly points out steps that could have saved the President alot of work at this point, and improved the approach to the Slick now slamming the Gulf Coast.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sierra Club has posted a link that people can contribute their own thoughts or letter to the President about the Oil Disaster. and if you want to follow Sierra Club's work and ongoing updates on the Gulf Disaster you can click this link and learn more.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

OIL DISASTER IN THE GULF : DAY 30 Oil Slick Spreads


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

May 17th NASA photo clearly shows the slick being drawn SE into currents towards Florida
NASA has larger photo with analysis that really shows the Oil being drawn to the Currents and the SE Loop.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Today's Post is on the continuing growth of the Slick, and reports of Tar Balls and the actual Slick reaching Shorelines. It also has Updates on EPA reports, Dispersant Issues, and Health issues. As well as Wildlife Updates. You can still follow me on Twitter @watergatesummer .
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Updates on Growth of the Slick,Tarballs on reaching Shores.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NOLAnews ( Times Picayune ) has article " Louisiana warns BP: You're cleaning up any oil that gets near coastline".The Times has updated daily what is happening along the Gulf Coastline and what is at stake. This fine NOLA paper has since day one been asking the hard questions and explaining the damage and damage perdictions.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Oil coats beach sand at the mouth of the Mississippi River on May 17, 2010 south of Venice, Louisiana.
More from TIME
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sattelite and aerial photos/images for Monday May 17th are raising concerns that the Oil is now reaching the SE Current Loop and will reach the Florida Keys within the next week. There also was a report of Tar Balls being found in the Keys today.( Those Tarballs were sent by BP to a Lab in NJ today, why EPA did not test them I am not certain). Articles about all these issues are below. ( Will update throughout the week of Where Tarballs and Slicks are being reported.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Christian Science Monitor has updates from May17th, explaining concerns about the Slick now being possibly directed by currents to Florida shores.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NPR has story up asking serious questions about daily volume being spewed, worries that the volume might be 10 Times what the public has been told by BP. The Video in this story is astounding and worth seeing.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Reuters explains how as the Slick Widens the Fishing Ban has had to be enlarged. We have not been given updates yet by the Media as to the true devastation this presents to the Fishing Industry in the Gulf. But Lawsuits are beginning to be filed.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Senator Nelson has a full Video Collection on his YouTube Channel where he has been posting the videos related to the spill, it is worth seeing as the Loop and the Currents and Slick Path is Explored. 20 Tar Balls were found today on the Beaches on the Florida Keys, the Tarballs supposedly were sent to NJ to be analyzed and determine if they are BP oil. @SkyTruth posted video today from Bill Nelon's YouTube site,At last video of the secondary leak just above the BOP - long video, sharp, shot on May 16 which raises signifigant questions about How Much is pouring from the two other "Lesser Leaks" that we don't know about. Times Picayune (NOLANews.com) and SkyTruth really have been giving helpful updates daily. SkyTruth Video continues to ask great questions.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
As the Slick grows and the now the Heavier Oils do reach the Shores, there has been oil creeping into the Louisiana Marshes, as the Tar balls reach Florida.Alabama and Mississippi Coastlines still are being monitored.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Already BP is trying to control the Reporting and the Data collection. Today CBS tried to report on Oily Beaches and ran into Conflict as the Coast Guard threatened to arrest reporters as they filmed. They are taking orders from BP, it can not be emphasized enough that BP should not prevent Freedom of the Press or the Truth being shown and Told to the Public. There are Right To Know Laws that maybe we need to remind DC about. Already NOAA, EPA and Coast Guard are removing Data , reports and photos from Websites. This is a Matter of Public Safety and must be confronted head on. This is the Link to CBS and their Report on what happened when they attempted to report the Coastal damage. No Journalists of Citizen Journalists should be threatened with Arrest. Citizens who live on the Coast, and make their home there also should not be intimidated or harrassed for wanting to see or report the Damage to their Coastline.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
UPDATES ON WILDLIFE
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

166 Turtles have rolled up on Shore dead, necropsies have not been completed yet, but NOAA and Fed Fish and Wildlife supposedly are investigating the deathes of these creatures. The concern is that they spend alot of time in the Deep Sea and may have been exposed to the Oil Slick but also to the Dispersant.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
IBRRC ( International Bird Rescue) has more about the Bird that it has cared for , most of the birds have been the Brown Pelican which is the State Bird of Louisiana and once was on the Endangered Species List. They are caring for the oiled birds and have already brought 4 back that were oiled, cared for, recovered and released. IBRRC
Northern Gannets, Brown Pelicans lead list of oiled birds we have in care; 4 already released and they are caring for others. You can follow them on Twitter @IBRRC. Also @DawnDishSoap is a great follow on Twitter as they give updates.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
UPDATE ON HEALTH ISSUES
Residents of the Gulf Coastal areas already are voicing concerns on Twitter and complaining of Fumes and also the People working on the Sea as part of the Disaster Process with their boats, are having complaints of Lung and respiratory complaints, I am unclear if OSHA is monitoring them or WHO is monitoring their health and making certain that they have the appropriate protective gear. BP and EPA have both been secretative about
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The DISPERSANT issue
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
COREXIT has been approved by EPA to be used on the Spill, 476,000 gallons were used in first three weeks, 216,000 gallons are left of the World Supply. IT has never been used in such huge volumes or as a Delayed response tactic. As of so far the Product has not been properly tested in Air,Water or soil or risks to Sea Workers or Wildlife and the workers caring for them. There are scientists stepping forward and voicing concerns for the Questionable practices being shown with this Compound.
The EPA own fact sheets state that it contains Heavy Metals and cyanide. A lighter version of the mixture supposedly contains Kerosene. BP has been attempting to paint is as harmless,like Dish Liquid.But none of the literature states ANY resemblence to soap.( Article linked is from Fast Link). So far 166 Sea Turtles have turned up dead ( this is not normal), 7 dolphins, atleast 7 oiled birds. People of the region remain concerned as they are TOLD TO call BP with Oiled Birds or creatures. ( On Twitter people continue to be encouraged to call DWF or Sierra Club or International Bird Rescue for advice of WHO to tell of Damaged creature).

The Concern about this Compound is that it also may pose risks for the Fishermen who are helping with the Sea Operations and are breathing the fumes of the Dispersant as well as the Oil, are they at risk for Lung or Respiratory Damage? Is OSHA issuing warnings or equipment or Health Monitoring ? ( I am emailing OSHA I will post responses in Comments when or if they arrive).

On another level there has been no discussion of the possible ramifications or damage of more than 700,000 Potent Chemicals entering the Fragile Gulf Food Chain for thousands of Sea Animals ( Fish and mammals).

Snippet From the Fast Company Article:
"UPDATE: In a statement to the Gulf Oil Disaster Recovery Group, toxicology expert Dr. William Sawyer elaborated on the risks associated with Corexit. According to Sawyer, Corexit is also known as deodorized kerosene--a substance with health risks to humans as well as sea turtles, dolphins, breathing reptiles, birds, and any species that need to surface for air exchanges."

What is causing the most Confusion , Deepwater Horizon Site has different information, than the EPA and NALCO, so unless there is transparencies as to what is entering the Sea and effecting Workers and Sealife and Mammals, none of the damages or risks can be properly assessed.

Senator Markey is the first Senator to step forward and voice Concerns about the use of COREXIT, he is speaking out and has written to the EPA about his concerns regarding the potential Toxicity and monitoring.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
In Gulf Spill, BP Using Dispersants Banned in U.K. by ProPublica.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
COREXIT are banned in the UK and Huffington Post has why it is banned and explained the problems it presents.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
EPA'S RESPONSE REGARDING DISPERSANT USE-their new fact sheet as of today.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Other Updates from this Week
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Kevin Costner has been working on investing in an Innovative Company that is studying Oil Seperation. He is willing to put more money into this research and help the Gulf. Do read this link about his efforts, it would be wise at this point for everyone to be willing to be creative and help the Gulf. I hope that BP, NOAA , EPA and the Coast Guard realize that Disasters of this scope require Transparency and Problemsolving involving the Public.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Oil Drum has the latest updates on the Siphon process that is worth reading and the Comments are really educational as well. I for one am very confused, if they are gathering one or two thousand barrels a day, but if they are Siphoning and collecting that oil,shouldn't there be easily accessible Data ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
LA Times has their latest update and it focuses on what the efforts are and how the slick is presenting new challenges.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Another copy of the Full Letter Senator Markey wrote to EPA Director Lisa Jackson.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Seafood Resturantes and Suppliers have already started to Sue BP, this has not been reported by Big Media, but local media on the Gulf is starting to Report.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
If you want to help,Volunteer or Donate you can still read more of this post. Thank you for caring for the Gulf.

Friday, May 14, 2010

President Obama Fuming in Rose Garden Blasts BP (Friday May 14th)


News Junkie has a good post about the President speaking in the Rose Garden on Friday May 14th.

OILSPILL UPDATE...Friday May 14th Oil Slick Grows in the Gulf


(Boston Globe photo from May 12th)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The Actual Video that it took BP over 3 weeks to Release to the Public showing the Gusher 5000 feet down via Think Progress and NWF:

Here is the the Think Progress post about the Gusher, and do read the comments where some educated people have weighed in, including people asking WHICH pipe is this-the 16 inch pipe? the 21 inch pipe?
LA TIMES has placed the leak up to 10-14 times higher than we have been told, instead of 5000 barrels daily, more like 70,000 barrels/daily.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Truthout is one of the first journals to raise the Criminal Question,may others start to ask more questions about this situation,an Explosion that killed 11,injured 17 and now is damaging an entire Body of Water and shoreline of possible 5 states and maybe even Mexico. How CEOs have conducted themselves at the Hearings and how they have hid the Footage raises new questions.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
New information on how Big the Disaster really is, today Scientists and Experts Weighed in on the amounts of Oil Gushing, New Estimates say it's a Exxon Valdez every 4 days.... At first we were told 1000 barrels day, then 2000, and now we realize we really don't know. But all new estimates are well above 5000 barrels day, which is more than 210,000 gallons /day, more like 250,000 to ONE million gallons per day. But it seems that the Footage of the Flow can and should be calculated by Experts to at least guess-estimate a more accurate Leaking Volume.
***~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~***
Late Thursday afternoon the Experts and Scientists started weighing in regarding size of the Oil "Leak", it is unclear if they were re-examining aerials or looking that the NEW video that it took 3 weeks for BP to publicly release. First it was NPR then NYT and by 5PM we learned that the White house is holding a special News Conference on the Spill tomorrow.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NYT has articles raising concerns about the size of the Spill and was it miscalculated and they raise more concerns about the shear daily volume that is still Leaking daily.The most striking analysis came from an Expert that has studied Oil Slicks using Aerials.
Snippet from NYT article 5.13.10
The criticism escalated on Thursday, a day after the release of a video that showed a huge black plume of oil gushing from the broken well at a seemingly high rate. BP has repeatedly claimed that measuring the plume would be impossible.The figure of 5,000 barrels a day was hastily produced by government scientists in Seattle.

It appears to have been calculated using a method that is specifically not recommended for major oil spills.Ian R. MacDonald, an oceanographer at Florida State University who is an expert in the analysis of oil slicks, said he had made his own rough calculations using satellite imagery. They suggested that the leak could “easily be four or five times” the government estimate, he said.

“The government has a responsibility to get good numbers,” Dr. MacDonald said. “If it’s beyond their technical capability, the whole world is ready to help them.”

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NPR released their article late afternoon raising their estimates to more than 5000 barrels /day, a Valdez every 4 day, and some estimates are even higher.

NPR Snippet
"NPR's Richard Harris has learned that much more oil, 70,000 barrels a day or more than ten times the official estimate, is gushing into the Gulf of Mexico from the Deepwater Horizon pipe, based on scientific analysis of the video released Wednesday.That's the equivalent of one Exxon Valdez tanker full every four days.
The U.S. Coast Guard has estimated that oil was gushing into the ocean at the rate of 5,000 barrels a day. But, again, NPR has been told that estimate is very low."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
@mnphysicist contributed this info re: oil flow calculations (based on videos&NPR articles) is a discussion and info posted on the Oil Drum where people are trying to estimate more about the Size and Volume of the Spill.
Math Notes from the Oil Drum based on the Pipe Video:Math details:
Pipe diameter is roughly 16 inches (0.4 meters), estimated using this photo with 12-inch wrench for scale.

From video, looking at motion of black stuff (oil) *only* and ignoring the much faster white stuff (gas), black stuff goes 1 pipe diameter in about 0.4 seconds, giving a speed of about 1 m/s.

Notice flow out of pipe is separated: gas in the top half, oil in the lower half. To get oil volume, multiply area of lower half of pipe times oil velocity:
0.5 * pi * (.2 m)^2 * 1 m/s = 0.06 m^3/s = 30,000 barrels/day

(Possible errors of 50% or so in oil velocity, cross-sectional area of oil flow, and in the assumption that the black stuff is 100% oil, for a cumulative factor of 2 uncertainty.)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Raw Story has more estimates and concerns, but at this point no one that has seen the Video of the Gusher one mile down has any encouraging words, or lower estimates. It is unfortunate that BP hid this important scientific evidence that Scientists and Engineers needed. It might even be Criminal at this rate.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
MORE NEW PHOTOS FROM THE GULF AND VIDEO
***~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~***
Stunning photos from the Gulf showing the many parts of this situation from the Boston Globe.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
More Gulf aerials and photos from Flyovers today by Gulf Restoration Network.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
(reported by @Treehugger) Damage is beginning to be measured and seen as it reaches different parts of the Shoreline and Gulf Islands and Barriers. The first Fish Kill is On Dauphin Island,Alabama from last night.
Here is the actual video and footage of the Fish Kill-more than 300 fish, mostly large in Size. The Question is what killed these full grown fish, was it the Oil ? The Fish they ate ? or the Dispersant ? or the Chemicals that were used by the Military near Dauphin Island.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Raccoon Island (Bird Sanctuary)of Louisiana has found damaged and dead animals that clearly point to Oil Damage. St.Bernards Parrish,Terrebonne and other parishes are readying for the Oily Mess. ( I will update more on this tomorrow).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Fishing Families line up for food,services and assistance from Catholic Charities In Louisiana,many live week to week on Fishing Earnings and there are no earnings right now. 2nd Harvest and Catholic Charities are both collecting for our Neighbors in the Gulf:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Actual Bird struggling against the Oily Mess Sunday ( Boston Globe)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

First oil soaked Pelican getting care, do see more photos on Boston Globe link below.If you want to help of donate to Animal and Wildlife care here is the link that has all the phone numbers and organizations that are helping in the Gulf from NWF to Sierra Club to NRDC to Audobon Society.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
OTHER IMPORTANT UPDATES:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Mexico's Officials has started to raise concerns as the Slick moves in a westerly direction and Hurricane Season approaches.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
EPA Director arrived today in NOLA and this is about her visit, as Fishermen are getting concerned about the situation, it is good that she is back.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The Governors Office of Louisanna has Twitter page has updates that are really helpful about staging,damages, organized efforts. Worth checking a few times a day.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
WSJ reported today that the TransOcean is trying to limit it's Liability to 27Million.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BP is still refusing to even TRY HairBooms or HairMats to absorb the Oil Slick ( which astounds me -as they Leak Gushes on with no Relief and they talk about shooting golfballs and tires at it ?) Science Daily explains how the Hair Booms Work. And in spite of BP's stubborness on this issue, Matter of Trust Org is already collecting hair for this cause as they know it has worked on the California Coasts, I encourage you to read their website.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BBC is asking questions about the Delay in the Disaster Response, asking why was the Response delayed.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Oil spill video: Times-Picayune reporters give latest updates and coverage.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Audobon Magazine has update on sealife,
Spill update: Oil might've killed 87 sea turtles, 18 birds, 6 dolphins; oil industry tax hike; leak video.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Once again Huffington Post has devoted a whole page to this situation. It is to be noted that Think Progress and Truthout and Raw Story and many other blogs have really been tracking Whistleblower concerns, Animal damage and reports from the Gulf States.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Note from Enigma: So as this week ends the Gulf Shorelines have started to see tarry blobs/balls roll up on shore and first dead animals,fish,dolphins(6) and turtles(28) and injured birds. Many are also starting to ask questions about the large volume of dispersant that has been used CorExit it is called, 450,000 gallons have been used, largest amount ever. I am trying to find information about this chemical and have been writing to the Care orgs and even BP asking if the dead animals have been tested for this chemical. As the Gusher continues we need to ask questions about the Huge volume of thick gooey crude oil and the Methane, and what will help the situation at this point. Many want The Gusher capped, but so far that has not been successful by BP. I also don't know when or why the Obama Administration has not declared it a National Disaster yet ? The National Guard and the different Parrishs are trying all kinds of solutions from Sand bags to Hay and others are asking for HairBooms. At this point 5 states are staring at a Massive Disaster, we in other states do need to think of how we can help our Neighbors. Especially after watching the CEOs dodge their responsibilities this week at the Hearings, Corporate Greed will not aid our Neighbors.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Please see Post below with Dangerous Questions about the Dispersant that has been used: IMP.

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

OILSPILL Update ....May 10-May 12th Latest from the Gulf Disaster


ABC this am Tuesday May 12th is running story of how BP is refusing to release the Video of the "Leak" and the underwater footage. This photo shows that they can message all they want-the leak 21 days in does appear to be gushing.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

May 8th photos LATimes. NYT maps out how the damage could spread due to Winds.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
{Enigma Note: I am still at this point just posting important links and updates of the Gulf Disaster, and dissect the pieces that might get missed. As the tarry oil clobs reach shore the extent of this disaster will become clearer. At this point I am still gathering info from Twitter as people post news directly from the Gulf. The Ecosystem and an entire way of life is at risk.Hearings are on the Hill this week, but so far it is mostly fingerpointing and a Blame game.} One disturbing detail that came out today at the Hearings was that the Safety data was not properly collected or monitored by the Drill Inspectors. Halliburton,TransOcean , and BP are all fingerpointing. If they are so hellbent on finding blame,maybe they should ALL share the blame,because 21 days in, it is a legacy they all can and will share.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

USA Today video is a must see, really shows what is going on today,especially along the Gulf Coastal Islands.Aerial Footage shows how horrific it is. (Alabama Register) The Hearings today were concerning as the blame flew around the room and inhibited factfinding and problemsolving, CS Monitor has more about the Hearings that explores what was discussed and not discussed.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The Government has the most complete page that is updated daily includes updates from Interior and Fish and Wildlife and NOAA. Over the weekend the 4 story dome that BP lowered down failed,so as of now, BP is still trying to dig 2 other relief wells ( which will take 3 weeks at least to complete). Now as of tonight they are attempting a new structure, smaller called a Top hat. The other cap failed due to ice crystals forming,created by the methane that is also leaking at the site. Another concern is that the original Explosion was caused by Methane.When the barge was sitting over the site of the leak this weekend, there was information on twitter ( not CNN) that the barge was suffering effects of Fumes and also that the workers were having to wear masks and be monitored, as well as explosion/ignition risks.

Here is more from the NOAA site that is and all their efforts that are currently being deployed. Here is more about the new Containment vessel the "Top hat" as explained by BP.

At this point it is important that the safety of all those trying to aid the operation be also protected. BP is asking fisherman to help with the operations, but we need to also be aware that they are at risk as they try to save their livelihoods and their ecosystem.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Many have been trying to find out about the wildlife and the risks. So far the 28 Sea Turtles that died it was said by different groups that they ate contaminated food (fish). Today there were reports of 6 dolphins found dead. It's important to note that for many of the species at risk, that these marshes wetllands and grounds are their breeding grounds and also where they raise their young, the effects will be devastating on multiple levels. CBS reported on the dolphins in a way that is disturbing. Much of the media is handling this disaster with kid gloves, it is questionable when the gloves come off. NRDC has a whole post about all the animals at risk, from the Turtles and dolphins to the Bluefin tuna.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Seafood Industries already examining Layoffs while the Oil halts fishing. BP hopefully will pay many of the fishermen that are helping with the Oil Cleanup.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sierra Club has updates and page that is full of updates that is constantly updated and worth reading and following as they are covering all the Gulf Concerns. Sierra Club has started asking some questions regarding the Safety and Preparedness that is a must read, and needs closer examination.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Another group that is working hard to follow the efforts in the Gulf is Jacques Costeau's family and organization their website is following the situation closely.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Karen Beninato of NOLA posted this and gave the perspective that is a must see, it will make you see it from a whole another point of view.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BP posted on Twitter their efforts, today it was about more Booms being brought in.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BP posted other efforts on Twitter about their deep sea efforts using robotics.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Russia has even offered help with the Oil Slick.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BBC has great article on the HairBoom Technology and how it works, but it is unclear at this point if BP is willing to try it, although people are collecting hair already. ( In NOLA they are already having HairBoom parties and saving hair and nylons. The National Guard is already trying other efforts of making sand walls. Other parrishes are examing using Hay to sop up the oily mess.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
More to be posted Wed.May 12th.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
If you want to help in the Gulf here is the post that has all the Links and info.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
May 12th Wed. Update from the Hearings::
Updated by Huffington Post goes into detail about series of errors and problems that created the Disaster we are now witnessing.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I encourage you to visit this Link from NASA as it shows all of the work that they are contributing to assisting with this Disaster in the Gulf. Really great work, that shows again why we need NASA.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
USAToday has illuminating article about the Safety Issues at the Oil Rig that were revealed today at the Hearings, from hydraulic fluid problems, valve problems, monitor problems to missing batteries.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~